The usual problem is too much situation

Most STAR answers fail the same way. The speaker spends a minute setting the scene, rushes what they did, and ends with "and it went well." Interviewers are scoring decisions and results, so the part people cut is the part that counts.

A rough guide for the four parts: about 15% situation, 10% task, 50% action and 25% result. The builder shows your split as you type. It is a guide, not a rule; a short, clear answer with a slightly long setup still beats a perfectly balanced one with no number in it.

Situation: two sentences. Task: one sentence on what you, not the team, were responsible for. Action: the decisions in order, in the first person. Result: a number, or a plain statement of what changed, such as a process still in use or a client that renewed.

Once it reads well, say it out loud with a timer. Written answers always run longer when spoken. Then put it away and practice from four words of notes, so it does not sound recited.