Some job offers include a line about equity: a number of shares, units or options, sometimes with a dollar figure next to it. It is easy to read that figure as part of your pay. It might be. It might also be worth much less than it looks, or nothing at all, depending on what kind of equity it is, when it becomes yours and whether you can ever sell it.
None of that is hard to find out if you ask. Here is what to understand before you weigh an equity grant against salary.
If the offer mentions RSUs, that stands for restricted stock units. An RSU is a promise from the company to give you one share of its stock later, once you have stayed long enough for it to vest. You do not pay anything for RSUs, and they are not yours until they vest. On the day they vest, the shares are delivered to you and their value counts as income, so 100 RSUs vesting when the stock trades at $50 means $5,000 of taxable pay.
The three kinds you are most likely to see
| Type | What you get | What it is worth |
|---|---|---|
| Restricted stock units (RSUs) | A promise of shares, delivered in batches as they vest. You do not pay anything for them. | The share price on the day they vest, times the number of units |
| Stock options | The right to buy shares later at a fixed price, called the strike or exercise price | Only the gap between the share price and the strike price. If the share price never rises above it, nothing |
| Restricted stock | Actual shares granted up front, which you can lose if you leave before they vest | The share price, but with an early tax decision attached (more on that below) |
Options come in two tax types: nonstatutory options and incentive stock options, which are only for employees and get different tax treatment. Your grant documents will say which you have.
Vesting decides what is actually yours
Equity is almost never yours on day one. It vests over time, usually over several years, and often with a "cliff": nothing vests until you have been there a set period, commonly a year, and then a chunk vests at once. After that it tends to vest monthly or quarterly.
That schedule is the most important fact in the grant. A four-year grant is roughly a quarter of its headline value per year, and only if you stay. If you leave or are laid off before the cliff, you may get nothing. Unvested equity is usually forfeited when you leave, so the question to ask is not what the grant is worth but what you would walk away with after one year, two years and four.
Ask, too, whether the company gives refresh grants each year to people who stay. Without them, your total pay can drop sharply once the first grant finishes vesting.
How each kind is taxed
Each kind is taxed at a different point. In general, under IRS guidance:
- RSUs are generally not taxed when they are granted. They are taxed when they vest and the shares are delivered, at their value on that day, as income. Some employers cover the tax withholding by keeping back some of the shares. An 83(b) election, described below, is not available for RSUs.
- Nonstatutory options are usually not taxed when granted. When you exercise them, the difference between what the shares are worth and what you paid counts as income.
- Incentive stock options are not counted as regular income when you exercise them, but the alternative minimum tax may apply that year. To get the more favorable treatment on a sale, you generally have to hold the shares for at least two years after the grant and one year after you exercise.
- Restricted stock lets you choose to be taxed on the value when it is granted rather than when it vests, called an 83(b) election. You have 30 days from the date the shares are transferred to you, usually the grant date, to file it. It cannot be undone without IRS consent, and if you later forfeit the shares you do not get that tax back.
This is the part to take to a tax professional before you exercise anything or file an 83(b) election. The rules have details that depend on your situation, and the deadlines do not move.
Public or private: the question that changes the value
At a company whose shares trade on a stock exchange, vested shares have a market price and you can usually sell them, although some employees can only sell during set trading windows. You can see what they are worth today, even if that changes tomorrow.
At a private company, there may be no way to sell until the company is bought or goes public, which may never happen. Options there also cost money to exercise, and exercising can create a tax bill before you have any way to sell. The dollar figure in a private company offer is the company's own estimate, not a price anyone has agreed to pay for your shares.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What type of equity is it, and how many shares, units or options?
- For options: what is the strike price, and how many shares does the company have in total, so you can see your percentage?
- What is the vesting schedule, and is there a cliff?
- What happens to vested and unvested equity if I resign, or if I am laid off?
- For options: how long do I have to exercise after I leave? Incentive stock options generally keep their tax treatment only if you exercise within three months of leaving.
- What happens to the grant if the company is acquired?
- Are refresh grants normal for people in this role?
Get the answers in writing, in the offer letter or the grant agreement. A recruiter's verbal description is not the document that decides what you receive.
Weighing equity against salary
Salary is paid whether the company's shares rise or fall. Equity is not. A sensible way to compare offers is to count salary at full value. Count publicly traded RSUs at a cautious share price, and only for the years you expect to stay. Count private company equity as a possible bonus rather than as pay.
If you are negotiating, you can ask about either one. Salary is the part you are sure to receive. How to negotiate an offer without losing it covers how to ask for either.
Before you count equity as pay
- Know the type: RSUs, options or restricted stock.
- Know the vesting schedule and what you keep if you leave early.
- Know when tax is due, and talk to a tax professional before you exercise or file an 83(b).
- Know whether you can actually sell the shares, and when.
- Get every answer in the offer letter or grant agreement.
Count salary as pay. Count equity as pay only once you know when it vests and how you would sell it.



