Most people put a list of references together the night before someone asks for it, then send it without telling anyone on it. The reference gets a call out of nowhere about a job they have never heard of, and has to improvise.
A reference who knows what the job is and what to talk about sounds very different. That takes about fifteen minutes of your time per person.
Where references fit in the process
In our experience, employers usually ask for references near the end, after the final interview and often just before or alongside an offer. Some only check references for their top choice. That makes the request a good sign, and it means the call can confirm a decision or unsettle it.
They usually ask for three. Have a fourth ready in case one of them is traveling or slow to reply.
Who to pick
The strongest reference is someone who managed you recently and can speak to the kind of work the new job involves. After that, the order usually looks like this:
| Reference | What they can speak to |
|---|---|
| A recent manager | Your results, how you take direction and feedback, and whether they would hire you again. |
| A senior colleague or project lead | How you work day to day, and specific projects you shared. |
| A client or partner from another company | How you handle people outside your team. Useful for sales, service and consulting roles. |
| Someone you managed | How you lead. Worth including if the new role manages people. |
Skip friends and family, and skip anyone who has not worked with you in years unless the job is close to what you did together. A famous name who barely remembers your work helps less than an ordinary one who can give examples.
If you cannot use your current manager
In our experience, this is common and most employers understand it. If you are searching quietly, say so plainly when the list is requested:
"My current manager doesn't know I'm looking, so I've included my previous manager at [company] and a senior colleague from my current team who knows about my search. Once we've agreed terms, I'm happy for you to speak with my current manager too."
Only list a current colleague if you trust them with the news. How to job hunt without telling your boss covers the rest of a quiet search.
Prepare them before the call
Ask each person first, even if they said yes for a previous search. Then send a short note with everything they need:
- The job. The title, the company and a link to the posting.
- Who will call. The name of the recruiter or hiring manager, and roughly when.
- Two or three things to mention. Pick the parts of your work together that match what the new role cares about most, with a specific example for each.
- Anything that came up in interviews. If the employer asked about a gap, a weakness or a project, tell your reference so their answer fits yours.
"Thanks again for agreeing to be a reference. [Company] is hiring a [job title] and I'm in the final round. [Name] from their team may call this week. They seemed most interested in [skill or result], so it would help if you could mention [specific project] and how [result]. Here's the posting: [link]. I really appreciate it."
Background checks are a different thing
When the employer calls your references itself, the federal background-check rules below don't apply. When an outside screening company does the checking, they do, and they give you some rights.
According to the Federal Trade Commission, an employer has to get your written permission before it uses a background reporting company to check you. If something in that report leads the employer to turn you down, it has to give you a copy of the report and a summary of your rights first, and then tell you which company supplied it. You can dispute anything wrong with that company.
Some screening companies also interview people who know you about your character and reputation. The FTC calls this an investigative report. If an employer orders one, it has to tell you in writing, and you can ask in writing for a description of what the investigation covered.
Before you send your list
Three names, each one asked and briefed. A recent manager first. Correct phone numbers and email addresses, and a line under each name saying how you worked together and when. One spare ready if someone does not reply.
After the call
Thank each reference as soon as you hear they were contacted, and tell them how it turned out, whichever way it went. It also makes a yes more likely next time you ask.
If an offer follows, the next conversation is about terms. How to negotiate an offer without losing it picks up from there.
A reference who knows what the job is and what to talk about sounds very different from one who gets a call out of nowhere.



